A furnace makes heat by burning gas or using electric resistance, and you need a separate air conditioner for cooling. A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, and one unit heats and cools. Heat pumps usually cost more to install, furnaces often cost less up front, and the better choice depends on your ducts, fuel, bills and budget. If your furnace is the question, start with furnace repair and replacement.
Modesto has hot summers and mild winters. Climate data for 1991 to 2020 shows a July average high near 95 F and a January average high near 56 F with an average low near 39 F. That climate is part of why heat pumps get a close look here, and you should ask any specialist to explain their reasoning for your house.
What is the difference between a furnace and a heat pump?
A furnace creates heat. A gas furnace burns natural gas or propane, and an electric furnace uses heating elements. A heat pump moves heat from one place to another using refrigerant, like an air conditioner that can run in reverse. In summer it cools, in winter it heats from the same outdoor unit.
| Gas furnace | Electric furnace | Heat pump | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat source | Burns natural gas or propane | Electric resistance elements | Moves heat with refrigerant |
| Cooling | Separate AC needed | Separate AC needed | Built in |
| Fuel | Gas line or propane tank | Electricity | Electricity |
| Venting | Required | Not required | Not required |
Electric furnaces are simple and have no combustion, but they convert electricity to heat directly. Heat pumps are generally the more efficient electric option, because they move heat rather than create it.
How much does a furnace cost compared with a heat pump?
A new furnace averages about $4,800 installed nationally, with a typical range of $2,800 to $7,500. A central heat pump averages about $8,350, with most installs between $5,000 and $15,000. These are national figures, not Modesto prices, and the actual quote depends on size, ducts and the work needed.
| Option | Published national installed range |
|---|---|
| Electric furnace | $1,800 to $7,300 |
| Natural gas furnace | $3,800 to $10,000 |
| Propane furnace | $3,700 to $14,200 |
| Central air-source heat pump | $5,000 to $15,000 |
Source: Fixr new furnace and heat pump installation guides, checked Nov 2026.
The comparison is not complete without cooling. A furnace home still needs an air conditioner, and Fixr's 2026 guide puts the average installed central AC near $6,000, with a 3-ton range of $2,500 to $8,000. A heat pump replaces both, which closes much of the gap when you would replace both anyway. The page on heat pump cost breaks down the ranges, and replacement HVAC cost covers whole-system replacement.
Which costs less to run, a furnace or a heat pump?
It depends on your gas price, your electric rate, the efficiency of the equipment and how cold it gets. Heat pumps tend to use less energy for the same heat, but gas can be cheaper per unit of energy. In a mild winter the heat pump often has the edge, and a specialist can estimate it from your bills.

There is no honest single number. What decides it:
- Your electric rate and plan. Utility territory varies by address, and some Modesto addresses are served by the Modesto Irrigation District and others by PG&E. Check your bill.
- Your gas price, if you use gas, or your propane cost.
- The equipment rating. Split central AC under 45,000 Btu/h must meet 14.3 SEER2 in California (Southwest region), and heat pumps must meet 14.3 SEER2 and 7.5 HSPF2. Higher ratings use less energy.
- Your home. Insulation, ducts and windows matter as much as the equipment.
Online heat pump vs furnace calculators can help, but they depend on the inputs you give them. Use your actual bills: the monthly gas and electric charges for the last year, the size of the home and the age of your equipment. Treat the result as a rough guide, and ask for the same numbers from a specialist's written quote.
How long does each one last, and what do repairs cost?
Carrier's lifespan table lists 15 to 20 years for furnaces and 10 to 15 for heat pumps (its text gives a wider furnace range), as estimates, not promises. Repairs are similar in price: Fixr lists heat pump repair at an average of about $400 (range $150 to $650) and a typical furnace repair at $349 to $650.
Maintenance, installation quality and climate matter for both.
Parts differ:
- Heat pump parts: capacitor $100 to $400, reversing valve $350 to $700, compressor work varies widely between guides, and Fixr lists $600 to $3,000 (January 2026).
- Furnace parts: igniter $96 to $178, flame sensor $68 to $127, control board $390 to $725, blower motor $562 to $1,045, heat exchanger $1,346 to $2,673.
If you are weighing repair or replacement, see heat pump repair for the cooling-and-heating side.
What is the difference between a single-stage and a two-stage furnace?
A single-stage furnace runs at full output whenever it is on. A two-stage furnace has a low setting and a high setting, and runs on low most of the time. Two-stage models can run longer at a gentler output, which tends to give steadier temperatures and quieter operation, usually at a higher price.
Questions to ask a specialist:
- Does my home benefit enough from two-stage heat to justify the price?
- What is the efficiency rating on each model?
- Does the thermostat or control board support staging?
The price premium is a quote item, so compare it in writing.
Can I keep my furnace and add a heat pump?
Some homes pair a heat pump with a gas furnace as backup. This is a dual-fuel system, and it uses the heat pump in mild weather and the furnace in cold weather. It costs more than either alone, and it needs a compatible thermostat. In a mild climate, many homes do not need the furnace backup. Ask the specialist for both options.
Other decisions worth raising:
- Ductwork. Existing ducts may need repair or resizing. Fixr says duct repairs typically add $500 to $4,000.
- Electrical capacity. A switch to a heat pump may need a panel check.
- Permits and rules. Stanislaus County's planning fee schedule lists HVAC and wall or floor furnace permit fees. Confirm the current amount with the county before budgeting. For a Modesto city address, ask the building department, and confirm the code edition that applies to your permit.
- Rebates. Modesto Irrigation District has listed rebates for heat pumps and central AC in the past, but listings conflict. Confirm what is available with MID at (209) 526-7339 before relying on it.
How do I decide and get quotes?
Ask for written quotes for the options you are considering, including a like-for-like furnace and AC and a heat pump, with the same scope. Compare installed price, rated efficiency, warranty and what happens to your ducts. Check each contractor's CSLB license at cslb.ca.gov.
Questions to bring: what size do you recommend and how did you calculate it, what rebates apply, what is the permit plan and what is the total including removal of the old equipment.
Send your details on the price request page, and see the home page for more heating and cooling guides.
Questions people ask
How long does a furnace or heat pump replacement take?
A like-for-like replacement is often a one-day job, sometimes two. Switching from a furnace and AC to a heat pump, or fixing ducts, can take longer. Ask for the expected schedule and any permit inspection steps in the written quote.
What should I ask before I hire someone for a furnace or heat pump install?
Ask for the CSLB license number, a written quote, the equipment model and efficiency rating, who pulls the permit, and how the size was calculated. Ask what the warranty covers and who handles the refrigerant under EPA Section 608.
Do I need to be home for a furnace or heat pump install?
Yes, an adult should be home for the start, to show the equipment and approve any changes, and for the final walkthrough. The crew will need access to the indoor unit, the outdoor pad and the electrical panel.
Is a heat pump good for Modesto winters?
Winters here are mild compared with much of the country, so a heat pump is often a reasonable option. The answer still depends on your ducts, your equipment and your electric rate. Ask a specialist to explain the choice for your house, and compare the bills.
Is an electric furnace the same as a heat pump?
No. An electric furnace turns electricity into heat directly with elements, and has no cooling. A heat pump moves heat with refrigerant and can also cool. A heat pump is generally the more efficient electric choice, but it costs more to install.
Sources
- Fixr new furnace guide, published national cost guide, checked Nov 2026
- Fixr heat pump installation guide, published national cost guide, checked Nov 2026
- Fixr heat pump repair guide, published national cost guide, checked Nov 2026
- Fixr furnace repair guide, published national cost guide, checked Nov 2026
- Carrier: how long do HVAC systems last
- Carrier minimum efficiency standards
Last updated