If your gas furnace will not heat, repair is usually the first thing to price. Fixr's furnace repair guide (updated August 2025) lists a typical range of $349 to $650, with the exact bill set by which part failed and when the visit happens. Replacement is a separate decision, and it tends to come up only for older units or very expensive parts.
This page covers how to tell a furnace is failing, who can legally work on one in California, what repairs cost, and when to stop repairing. For sudden, unsafe or middle-of-the-night failures, see emergency furnace repair. To compare actual quotes for your own unit, use the quote request form.
How do you know your furnace is broken?
A furnace is broken when the house does not warm up after the thermostat calls for heat, or when it runs in a way it never did before. The usual signs are no heat, cold air from the vents, a burner that lights and shuts off, new banging or squealing, a pilot or igniter that never glows, or a rising bill with no change in weather.
Start with the checks that cost nothing. Confirm the thermostat is set to heat and the batteries are fresh. Check that the breaker has not tripped and that the filter is not clogged. A clogged filter restricts airflow and can make a furnace shut itself off to protect the unit. A guide to furnace filter change schedule shows what to look for.
If none of that helps, stop there. Anything inside the cabinet, and anything touching the gas line, is work for a pro. Different symptoms point to different parts:
| What you notice | Parts a specialist often checks |
|---|---|
| Clicking, then no flame | Igniter, gas supply, gas valve |
| Flame lights, then dies in seconds | Flame sensor |
| Blower runs but air is cold | Burner, control board, gas valve |
| Fan will not start | Blower motor, capacitor, control board |
| Shuts off before the house is warm | Limit switch, airflow, thermostat |
| Furnace will not start at all | Thermostat, pressure switch, inducer motor |
These are general patterns from industry troubleshooting guides and furnace manuals. The specialist who opens the cabinet confirms the real cause.
Do plumbers fix furnaces?
Sometimes, but the license matters more than the job title. In California, the C-20 classification from the Contractors State License Board covers warm-air heating systems, including controls, flues and filters. A plumber may or may not hold that classification, so ask which license the person holds and check it yourself at cslb.ca.gov.
California requires a CSLB license for work valued at $1,000 or more in labor and materials. Splitting one job into smaller invoices does not get around the license requirement, so treat it as a warning sign. A basic furnace repair often comes in under $1,000, but a control board, blower motor or heat exchanger job can pass it.
Whatever the price, the same check applies: look the license up before work starts, and never accept a license number you cannot verify. On this site, quotes come from independent local businesses, not from us, so the license check is yours to do with each one. See how this works for what happens after you send a request.
What is the 5,000 rule for furnace?
The 5,000 rule is a common rule of thumb, not from a manufacturer, and not a law. Multiply the repair cost by the furnace's age in years. If the result is above 5,000, replacing usually makes more sense than repairing. A $400 repair on a 15-year-old furnace scores 6,000, which leans toward replacement. The same repair on a 6-year-old unit scores 2,400.
Carrier's guidance is that repairs that approach 50 percent of a new system's cost favor replacement. Neither test accounts for your repair history or your gas bill. Treat the result as a reason to ask a specialist for two numbers: the repair and the replacement.
For a new furnace, Fixr's published guide shows a national average around $4,800, with a typical range of $2,800 to $7,500 installed. The furnace replacement cost page breaks that down by fuel type, and furnace vs heat pump helps if you are weighing a different system altogether.
Who installs wall heaters?
A wall heater, or wall or floor furnace, is installed and changed out by a California contractor holding the right CSLB license, usually the same C-20 warm-air heating classification. Stanislaus County's planning fee schedule lists HVAC and wall or floor furnace permit fees. Confirm the current amount with the county before budgeting.
Whether a like-for-like swap inside Modesto city limits needs a permit was not confirmed from a City of Modesto source. Ask the building department, and ask your specialist who pulls the permit and who pays for it. If a contractor says no permit is needed, ask them to put that in writing in the quote.
Wall units are also gas appliances. Do not light, move or modify one yourself. The same carbon monoxide risks apply as with any fuel-burning heater, which is why the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends a professional inspection of fuel-burning heating systems every year.
What does furnace repair cost in Modesto?
Fixr's furnace repair guide (updated August 2025) lists a typical range of $349 to $650, and a full spread of part prices from $66 up to $2,673. No source gave Modesto-specific prices.
Part prices from Fixr's furnace page, which include the service call:
| Repair | Published range |
|---|---|
| Limit switch | $66 to $122 |
| Flame sensor | $68 to $127 |
| Igniter | $96 to $178 |
| Control board | $390 to $725 |
| Blower motor | $562 to $1,045 |
| Heat exchanger | $1,346 to $2,673 |
Labor on that page runs $87 to $162 per hour. A diagnostic or service call fee is often $75 to $250 and is sometimes credited toward the repair if you hire the same company. Nights, weekends and holidays cost more: see emergency furnace repair for surcharges. A control board is one of the few jobs where the quote can fall close to replacement territory, so get a second written quote.
Price depends on the part, the labor time, your furnace's age and brand, and whether the visit is scheduled or urgent. Brand names such as Payne, Coleman, Heil, Tempstar, Comfortmaker and Luxaire do not change the process. Tell the specialist the brand, the model number from the data plate, and the fuel (natural gas, propane or electric) so the quote is accurate. Propane units may involve different parts and gas handling, so ask whoever quotes it to confirm they work on propane. A technician for your brand is simply someone who can get the part.
What is the life expectancy of a furnace?
Carrier's lifespan table lists 15 to 20 years for a furnace, though its text gives a wider range. That is an estimate, and maintenance, installation quality and how hard the system runs all move the number.
Heating matters on the AC Repair Modesto Quotes home page as much as cooling does. Modesto's heating season is mild compared with colder states. Climate data for 1991 to 2020 shows a January average high near 56 F and a low near 39 F, so a furnace here runs fewer hours than one in a cold climate. That does not stop parts wearing out, and it does not remove the safety need for regular inspection.
When a furnace is past about 15 years and repairs are piling up, ask a specialist for a replacement quote next to the repair quote. The whole-system replacement cost guide shows how whole-system prices compare, and furnace repair and service explains the yearly checkup that helps units reach their expected life.
If you are still deciding who to call, read how to judge a specialist before you accept a quote.
Questions people ask
Should a 25 year old furnace be replaced?
Usually yes, once repairs start. A 25-year-old furnace is past the 15 to 20 year range in Carrier's lifespan table. A single cheap part is still worth fixing, but a control board, blower motor or heat exchanger quote on a unit this age often makes replacement the better use of the money.
What's the average life span of a furnace?
Carrier's lifespan table lists 15 to 20 years, and its text gives a wider range. These are estimates, not promises. Yearly maintenance, correct installation and a clean filter all help a furnace reach the upper end.
Can a heat exchanger be replaced?
Yes, but it is one of the most expensive furnace repairs. Fixr lists heat exchanger work at $1,346 to $2,673 on its furnace page. A cracked heat exchanger can let combustion gases, including carbon monoxide, into the home. On an older furnace, many people replace the unit instead.
How much does it cost to fix your furnace?
Fixr's furnace repair guide lists a typical range of $349 to $650. Small parts such as a flame sensor or limit switch can be under $200, while a blower motor or control board often costs more. Get the price in writing before work starts.
What is the most common problem of a furnace?
Published guides do not agree on one ranking. Airflow problems from a dirty filter are the easiest to prevent, and ignition parts such as the igniter and flame sensor appear on every furnace repair price list. If your furnace lights and then shuts off, read about the flame sensor.
Read on
- Change a furnace filter
How to change a furnace filter step by step: find it, read the size and MERV rating, install it facing the right way, plus furnace reset…
- Furnace filter schedule
How often to change a furnace filter in Modesto and the Central Valley: schedules for dust, smoke, pets and thick filters, plus how to…
- Furnace repair near me
Furnace heating repair near me: what to do in the first hour with no heat, how 24-hour help works in Modesto, what after-hours calls cost…
- Furnace repair and service
Furnace repair and service explained by symptom: heat on but furnace not running, fan works but no heat, lights then shuts off, plus how…
- Emergency furnace repair
No heat, a gas smell or a carbon monoxide alarm?
- Furnace replacement cost
Furnace replacement cost explained: national price ranges by fuel type, repair prices for common parts, and what to ask before you accept…
- Furnace vs heat pump
Furnace vs heat pump: compare install and repair costs, lifespan and running costs, and see which suits a mild Modesto winter and hot…
- Choosing a specialist
How to judge a heating and air specialist in Modesto: check the CSLB license, get a written quote, and know which questions and red flags…
- Gas furnace repair
Gas furnace not heating? See the common causes, what you can check safely, published repair cost ranges and why gas and CO risks need a…
Sources
- Fixr furnace repair cost guide (updated August 2025)
- Carrier, How long do HVAC systems last
- CPSC, Carbon monoxide fact sheet
- CSLB, What kind of contractor do you need
Last updated
