A new gas furnace, installed, typically costs between $2,800 and $7,500 in published national price guides, with a national average near $4,800. A single repair to the one you already have usually costs a few hundred dollars. The gap between those two numbers is the whole decision. This page covers both, so you can compare a repair quote with a replacement quote. For repair work and how it is handled, see furnace repair and replacement. All figures here are national guides, not Modesto quotes.
How much does it cost to fix your furnace?
Fixr's furnace repair guide (updated August 2025) lists a typical range of $349 to $650. Small parts sit at the bottom of the range and a failed heat exchanger or blower can push past it. Fixr lists a service call alone at $75 to $250.
| Repair | Published national range |
|---|---|
| Flame sensor (call plus part) | $68 to $127 |
| Igniter (call plus part) | $96 to $178 |
| Limit switch | $66 to $122 |
| Control board | $390 to $725 |
| Blower motor | $562 to $1,045 |
| Heat exchanger | $1,346 to $2,673 |
These come from the Fixr furnace repair guide (August 2025). Labor in that guide is $87 to $162 per hour. The final quote depends on your unit and your home.
How much is the average cost of a new furnace?
The national average for a new furnace installed is about $4,800, with most homes landing between $2,800 and $7,500, according to the Fixr new furnace guide checked Nov 2026. That figure includes the unit and the labor. It does not usually include new ductwork, a new thermostat, or permit costs.

Furnace labor alone runs $300 to $1,800 in the same guide, and a straight swap takes 4 to 10 hours. If the crew has to modify venting, a gas line or the platform the furnace sits on, expect hours and cost to grow.
How much should it cost to replace a gas furnace?
For a natural gas furnace, the Fixr guide lists $3,800 to $10,000 installed, a higher band than the all-fuel range. Where you land inside it depends on the unit and the job.
What moves a gas furnace quote:
- Efficiency. A higher-efficiency unit costs more, and some need a condensate drain line run to a drain.
- Size. Ask whether the unit is sized to your home or just copied from the old one.
- Location. A furnace in a tight closet or attic takes longer than one in a garage or utility room.
- Venting and gas line. Old flue pipe or an undersized gas line adds work.
How much does an electric furnace replacement cost?
Electric models are cheaper to buy and install. The Fixr guide lists $1,800 to $7,300 for electric, against $3,700 to $14,200 for propane. Electric units have no flame, no flue and no gas line, so there is less to install.
The tradeoff shows up on your energy bills, not on the quote. Ask any specialist to explain running cost as well as the sticker price, and read furnace versus heat pump before you pick a fuel.
What is the most expensive part of a gas furnace to replace?
The heat exchanger is the costly one. Fixr lists $1,346 to $2,673 for the repair on its furnace page. A cracked heat exchanger can leak combustion gases, including carbon monoxide, so it is a safety issue as well as a money one.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission urges a professional inspection of furnaces and flues every year. If a pro tells you the heat exchanger has failed, ask to see the crack or the test result. On an older furnace, weigh that repair quote against a new unit.
What does a furnace repair cost compared with replacing it?
Two rules of thumb are common, though neither comes from a manufacturer. The first: if the repair costs more than about 50% of a new system, replacement usually makes more sense (Carrier says repair costs that approach 50 percent of a new system's cost point toward replacing). The second is a common rule of thumb, the 5,000 rule: multiply the furnace's age by the repair quote, and if the result is above 5,000, lean toward replacing. A 17-year-old furnace with a $400 repair gives 6,800, a lean toward replacement.
Carrier's lifespan table lists 15 to 20 years for furnaces, though its text gives a wider range, and it treats these as estimates, not promises. Carrier suggests considering replacement after about 15 years. Climate, installation quality and maintenance all matter.
What changes the price of a furnace replacement?
Six things move a quote more than the brand name does:
- Fuel type. Electric, gas, propane or oil, as in the ranges above.
- Efficiency rating. AFUE is the percentage of fuel turned into heat. Higher costs more up front and less to run.
- Capacity. Bigger units cost more, and an oversized furnace short-cycles.
- Labor and access. Attic, crawlspace and tight closets add hours.
- Permits. Stanislaus County's planning fee schedule lists HVAC and wall or floor furnace permit fees. Confirm the current amount with the county before budgeting. We could not confirm the rule for your city, so ask your building department.
- Extras. New thermostat, filter cabinet, line set, venting or a gas shutoff valve.
Questions to ask before you accept a furnace quote
Get at least two written quotes. California law requires a CSLB license for labor and materials of $1,000 or more (call 800-321-CSLB (2752); HVAC is class C-20), and a furnace replacement will usually pass that mark. Check the license number at cslb.ca.gov before work starts. Then ask each business:
- What exact model and efficiency rating are you quoting?
- Is the price installed, including venting, gas line, thermostat and haul-away of the old unit?
- Who pulls the permit, and is its fee in the price?
- Did you calculate the load for my home?
- What does the warranty cover on parts and on labor, and for how long?
Quotes come from independent local businesses. Use the price request form to describe your furnace and compare what comes back, or return to the home page to see what else the site covers.
Questions people ask
What is the most expensive thing to fix on a furnace?
The heat exchanger. Fixr puts the repair at $1,346 to $2,673. The control board comes next at $390 to $725, then the blower motor at $562 to $1,045. When a repair approaches half the cost of a new furnace, compare it against replacement.
What is the $5000 rule for furnace?
Multiply the furnace's age in years by the repair quote. If the number is above 5,000, a common rule of thumb, not from a manufacturer, says to lean toward replacing. A 15-year-old furnace with a $400 repair scores 6,000. It is a prompt to compare quotes, not a law, so also weigh how often the unit has failed.
What is the life expectancy of a furnace?
Carrier's lifespan table gives 15 to 20 years, and its text gives a wider furnace range. These are estimates. Maintenance, installation quality and how hard the furnace works move the real number.
When is the cheapest time of year to buy a furnace?
No published guide we reviewed named a month with lower prices. Furnace calls rise in the first cold snaps of autumn and winter, so a planned swap outside that rush may give you more choice of dates. Ask whether pricing changes by season.
Does furnace brand change the price?
Somewhat, but efficiency level, capacity and installation work usually move the quote more. Two quotes for different brands can look far apart because they bundle different extras. Ask for the model number and efficiency rating on every quote, then compare like for like, including the parts and labor warranty.
Sources
- Fixr furnace replacement cost guide, checked Nov 2026
- Fixr furnace repair cost guide, updated Aug 2025, checked Nov 2026
- Carrier, how long HVAC systems last
- CPSC news release on furnace safety
- CSLB, what kind of contractor do you need
Last updated
